What's up with this generation?

In a recent episode of TJF Talks, Shai Davidai, an Assistant Professor at Columbia Business School, shared insights into the current generation’s state and its connection to historical patterns of antisemitism. He joins to shed light on the challenges and opportunities facing young people today, drawing from a deeply personal narrative that includes his unexpected role as an “accidental activist.”

Davidai began by addressing a common perception of a corrupt generation, which he didn’t wholly agree with. While recognizing societal issues, he also highlighted the exceptional qualities of young Jewish individuals. He pointed out, “I’ve been meeting a lot of Jewish high school students, and they are way more incredible than my colleagues and I were at their age.” This observation underscores the potential of the upcoming generation to make positive changes.

The conversation also touched on a significant recent event, October 7th, and its lasting impact. Shai emphasized that the event has created a divide in society, making it difficult to change minds once they’re closed. “There’s nothing you can do to go and say, ‘I’m going to change your mind,’” he stated, highlighting the futility of trying to convince those unwilling to see the wrong in the tragedy. Instead, he suggested focusing efforts on educating the wider community on the event’s evil and urgent need for action.

Jewish identity and resilience emerged as a theme, with Davidai embracing the idea of Jewish continuity despite adversity. The conversation explored the cyclical nature of Jewish persecution and the historical context of antisemitism. Seth noted, “We’ve been talking about this, anticipating it. Jewish disunity leads to calamity.” This pattern has persisted, affecting humanities progress and highlighting the enduring resilience of Jewish communities.

Davidai also discussed the problematic role of universities in fostering biased viewpoints, particularly against Israel. He mentioned how some institutions are financially influenced by foreign entities like Qatar, which can exacerbate antisemitic rhetoric. He advocated for educational finance reforms to bring transparency and prevent such biased influences from spreading unchallenged narratives on campuses.

On the topic of activism, Davidai described himself as a “reluctant activist,” compelled to speak out despite personal costs. His viral video following October 7th was a raw expression of pain and a call to action. He explained, “I had an internal struggle, but this is bigger than any individual. I have a responsibility.”

University environments that support antisemitic views also came under scrutiny. Columbia University, among others, was named for its perceived complicity in allowing pro-terror organizations to influence students. Davidai’s experience there underscores the need for reform and greater accountability in institutions shaping young minds.

The conversation further explored the impact of foreign funding on education. Davidai stressed the need for transparency, questioning, “Who’s paying, and for what are they paying?” The influence of foreign money in shaping campus ideologies remains a pressing concern.

Unity emerged as a crucial element in counteracting these challenges. Though Jewish communities have historically faced division, the importance of coming together for collective action was emphasized. Shai stated, “We need to focus on the things where the Jewish people are collected and united.” This collective approach can drive meaningful change.

In combating hate, the discussion touched on practical strategies like community support and open dialogue. Engaging in constructive conversations, even amid disagreements, is critical in addressing bias and promoting empathy. Davidai noted the importance of empowering Jewish voices and encouraging allies to support Jewish communities against antisemitism.

The conversation concluded with a focus on education and awareness as long-term solutions. Emphasizing systemic change and promoting inclusive environments, both Shai and the hosts agreed that fostering empathy and understanding across diverse communities can help dismantle prejudice.

Ultimately, the discussion highlighted the paradox of the current generation, torn between historical patterns of persecution and the potential for positive transformation. Through advocacy, education, and unity, there’s hope to shape a future where Jewish communities thrive alongside others, rooted in mutual respect and understanding.